Surety Bond vs Bank Guarantee for Government Tenders in India: Rules, Acceptance and Real Cost

Summary

Since February 2022, GFR Rules 170 and 171 allow insurance surety bonds as bid and performance security alongside bank guarantees. They work like a bank guarantee for the buyer but need little or no cash margin. This guide covers acceptance rules, a cost comparison, and how to check your tender.

Key Highlights

  • Insurance surety bonds have been an accepted form of bid security (Rule 170(i)) and performance security (Rule 171(i)) under GFR 2017 since the Department of Expenditure's office memorandum dated 2 February 2022, on par with bank guarantees.
  • Acceptance is an option for the bidder, not an obligation for the buyer's paperwork.
  • The real saving is rarely the premium itself. It is the cash margin and bank limits you don't lock up, so compare firm quotes rather than headline rates.
  • Surety bonds are underwritten by IRDAI-licensed general insurers on your financial strength and track record, which means issuance time and eligibility look different from a bank guarantee.
AI-powered tender intelligence

For a contractor bidding on several tenders at once, a bank guarantee is never just a piece of paper. The bank usually asks for a cash margin or a fixed deposit lien, and the guarantee also eats into the credit limit you need for materials, wages and the next bid. Add an EMD for every bid and a performance security for every win, and the money parked with the bank can decide how many tenders you are able to take on.

That is the gap insurance surety bonds were meant to fill. In December 2022, the country's first surety bond insurance product was launched with the objective of reducing infrastructure developers' dependence on bank guarantees. In November 2023, NHAI accepted its first insurance surety bond as bid security for the Toll Operate Transfer Bundle 14 bid, with the insurer reportedly pricing it at 0.25% and asking for no margin money. By mid-2024, around 700 surety bonds worth roughly ₹3,000 crore had been issued by insurers, and NHAI alone had received 164 of them: 144 for bid security and 20 for performance security.

The legal footing for all of this came earlier. A Department of Expenditure office memorandum (F.1/1/2022-PPD, 2 February 2022) added insurance surety bonds to the instruments accepted under GFR 2017 Rules 170(i) and 171(i), covering both EMD and performance security. 

So the practical question today is less about whether the rules allow a surety bond, and more about whether your specific tender, buyer and insurer are set up to accept one. Read the blog to know how surety bonds differ from a bank guarantee, what the cost comparison really looks like, and how to check your tender before you decide to bid on it.

Bank Guarantee vs Insurance Surety Bond

Bank guarantee (BG). A bank promises the buyer it will pay up to a set amount if you default. In tenders, it is typically unconditional and payable on demand. To get one, you usually provide a cash margin or a fixed-deposit lien, and the BG uses up part of your non-fund-based credit limit.

Insurance surety bond. A three-party contract between you (the principal), the buyer (the obligee) and an IRDAI-licensed general insurer (the surety). If you default on your obligations, the insurer compensates the buyer up to the bond amount, and you owe the insurer under a counter-indemnity. IRDAI's Surety Insurance Contracts Guidelines, dated 3 January 2022 and effective 1 April 2022, are what allowed general insurers to issue bid, performance and advance payment bonds.

Side-by-side Comparison of Bank Guarantees and Surety Bonds

ParameterBank guaranteeInsurance surety bond
IssuerScheduled commercial bankIRDAI-licensed general insurer
Legal basis in tendersGFR 2017 Rules 170(i), 171(i)Same rules, as amended by DoE OM of 2 Feb 2022
CollateralTypically a cash margin or FD lien, often 10% to 25% or more depending on your credit profileLittle or none; secured through underwriting and a counter-indemnity
Effect on bank limitsConsumes non-fund-based limitsSits outside your bank credit lines
Cost componentsCommission, GST, stamp duty and renewals, plus the opportunity cost of the marginPremium, set by the insurer after underwriting
Typical indicative pricingVaries widely by bank and borrower profileCommonly quoted at around 0.5% to 3% a year, but firm pricing comes only from the insurer
Payout termsUsually on-demandDepends on the bond wording, so confirm it matches what the tender requires
Where it can be usedEMD, performance security, advance payment guaranteeBid, performance and advance payment bonds
Underwriting basisCollateral and credit limitsFinancial strength, track record, work in hand and project risk

What "Accepted" Really Means

Rules 170 and 171 are central government procurement rules, and the amendment simply adds surety bonds to the list of permitted forms. Four points follow from that.

  1. It is an alternative. You choose whether to use it. Nothing forces a bidder to switch away from a bank guarantee.
  2. The tender document still matters. Some notices of inviting tender still read "bank guarantee only" or list an older set of instruments. If yours does, raise a pre-bid query citing Rules 170(i) and 171(i) as amended and ask for the clause to be corrected, rather than assuming the bond will be accepted at submission.
  3. Not every buyer follows GFR. Defence procurement follows its own acquisition procedure, and many state governments and state PSUs run on their own rules. Confirm acceptance with each buyer.
  4. Acceptance can differ by type of security within the same tender. A bond that is accepted as bid security or base performance security may still be excluded for a specific requirement, as the highway rules on additional performance security below show.

Format also counts. The bond wording, validity and amount need to match what the tender prescribes, in the same way a bank guarantee has to follow the buyer's proforma.

Insurance Security Bond Acceptance Changes at NHAI in 2026

NHAI is the buyer where surety bonds have been tested the most, so its rules are a useful guide to how acceptance works in practice. The route so far looks like this:

  • 2023: The Ministry of Road Transport and Highways directed acceptance of insurance surety bonds and electronic bank guarantees as bid and performance security. NHAI's circular of 13 June 2023 updated its standard bidding documents for EPC, HAM and BOT (Toll) projects.
  • July 2025: A policy circular extended surety bonds to performance security in consultancy contracts for Authority Engineers and Independent Engineers.
  • February 2026: Policy Circular 11.84/2026, dated 13 February 2026, amended NHAI's standard bidding documents and formally recognised insurance surety bonds as valid bid security and performance security for works sanctioned at NHAI level, including EPC, O&M, non-regular civil works and black spot rectification.
  • July 2026: A Road Transport and Highways Ministry circular, effective immediately, asked for higher additional performance security from bidders quoting 30% or more below the project cost put to bid, on all future EPC, HAM and maintenance contracts. It also says that additional performance security can be furnished only as an e-bank guarantee, with surety bonds not accepted for it. 

For a bidder, the practical content of the 2026 circular is as follows:

  • Who can issue the bond: only insurers authorised by IRDAI.
  • Verification: the bond is authenticated through a designated online portal, so a bond that cannot be verified there is a problem at submission.
  • Wording: the bond must be an irrevocable and unconditional undertaking. For NHAI bids, this settles the payout-terms question from the comparison table above. Bank guarantees, for their part, must follow SFMS (Structured Financial Messaging System) norms.
  • No third-party facilities: performance security, and the additional performance security (APS) described below, backed by a third party's facility, is not accepted. The contractor must stand behind it directly.
  • Bid security in the prescribed form: if it is missing, the bid is treated as non-responsive. Withdrawing an offer, rejecting permissible corrections or failing to furnish performance security on time can lead to forfeiture and potential debarment.
  • Lower base performance security for EPC: for EPC works approved at NHAI level, the baseline performance security is 3% of the bid price.
  • APS for low bids: for bids priced well below the estimated cost, the circular set out a graduated APS formula, which forms part of the performance security. NHAI then revised the APS threshold and calculation again through Policy Circular 11.94/2026 of 19 June 2026, which applies to ongoing and future works, so check the latest circular before pricing an aggressive bid. A further ministry circular, described in the next section, adds another rule for very deep discounts.
  • Formats and rollout: the circular took immediate effect. Where bid due dates were already fixed, they were extended by seven days so that revised clauses and the annexed bank guarantee and surety bond formats could be incorporated. Use the annexed formats as they are.

The takeaway is less about the instrument being new and more about the conditions around it. If you plan to use a surety bond on an NHAI tender, decide between a surety bond and an electronic bank guarantee early, confirm your insurer's IRDAI authorisation and portal verification, and do not plan on relying on a third party's credit facility for performance security.

The Latest Catch: No Surety Bonds for Additional Performance Security

Surety bonds are not accepted for every part of a highway tender's security package. A Road Transport and Highways Ministry circular issued in July 2026, which came into force with immediate effect, asks for higher performance security from bidders who offer to build a project at 30% or more below the project cost put to bid. It applies to all future EPC, HAM and maintenance contracts on national highways. The ministry said it reviewed the issue because of a continuing trend of abnormally low quoting in national highway projects, and the aim is to deter such bids and protect the quality of the roads that get built.

As reported, the additional performance security (APS) for a bid discounted by 30% or more is raised by 0.5% for every percentage point of the bid price below the 30% mark, on top of 3% of the bid price. The reporting leaves some room for interpretation on exactly what base the increment is applied to, so work from the circular's own formula when you price.

For anyone planning to use a surety bond, the important part is the instrument. The circular says APS can be furnished only as an e-bank guarantee and that surety bonds will not be accepted for it. In practice:

  • A surety bond can still be used where the tender permits it for bid security and the base performance security, but the APS portion has to come from your bank.
  • For a deeply discounted bid, the working capital and credit limit you hoped to save with a bond are partly given back, because the largest and fastest-growing piece of the security is the one a bond cannot cover.
  • Confirm e-bank guarantee capacity with your bank before you bid at a deep discount, not after the Letter of Award.

The reporting does not say how this circular sits alongside NHAI's earlier APS formula, which used different discount thresholds and was revised in June 2026. The tender document will state which APS clause applies, so read it closely before you decide on your price and your choice of instrument.

Where the Cost Savings Really Come From

Published figures vary a lot. Surety premiums are commonly quoted at 0.5% to 3% a year, and bank guarantee commissions at anywhere from under 1% to around 4%, plus the margin your bank asks for. These ranges come largely from insurers and brokers, so treat them as indicative and ask for actual quotes.

Here is an illustration with clearly stated assumptions, not a benchmark. A ₹5 crore performance security held for three years:

Criteria

Bank guarantee

Surety bond

Annual charge1.5% commission = ₹7.5 lakh1.5% premium = ₹7.5 lakh
Three-year charge₹22.5 lakh₹22.5 lakh
Margin locked10% = ₹50 lakh in FDNil
Carrying cost of margin*About ₹8.25 lakh over three yearsNil
Effective costAbout ₹30.75 lakhAbout ₹22.5 lakh

*Assuming your business funds cost 12% while the FD earns 6.5%, a spread of 5.5% on ₹50 lakh for three years.

Two things stand out. First, at equal rates, the saving comes from the margin, not the premium: about ₹8 lakh in carrying cost, plus ₹50 lakh of liquidity and bank limit left free for your next bid. Second, the advantage is not automatic. If the insurer prices the same bond at 2.5% a year, the three-year charge becomes ₹37.5 lakh, which is above the bank guarantee's all-in figure in this example. The case for a bond is strongest when your non-fund-based limits are tight, or you are bidding on several tenders at once. On highway tenders where you quote a deep discount, remember that additional performance security has to be an e-bank guarantee, so the margin and limit you save applies only to the rest of the security.

When Each Option Tends To Make Sense

A bank guarantee still makes sense when the tender wording is bank-guarantee only, when you have ample unused limits and a low margin, or when you need the on-demand wording the buyer insists on. A surety bond tends to make sense when your limits are committed, when cash margin is the real constraint on how many tenders you can take on, and when the buyer's tender clearly permits it.

How to Use a Surety Bond in a Tender

  1. Read the security clauses first. Check which instruments are permitted for EMD, performance security, any additional performance security and any advance payment guarantee.
  2. Raise a pre-bid query if the clause is silent or says "BG only." Cite Rules 170(i) and 171(i).
  3. Approach insurers early. Underwriting takes your financials and order book into account, so don't start after the Letter of Award with a 15 to 30 day deadline running.
  4. Match the format. Bond amount, validity period and wording must follow the tender's proforma. For performance security that means covering the contract plus the required period beyond completion of obligations, including warranty.
  5. Check the insurer. It should be an IRDAI-licensed general insurer, and the buyer may ask for verification of the bond.

Where AI-based Document Reading Helps

The deciding detail, which instruments are allowed, in what format, for what amount and for how long- is hidden in clauses spread across a long tender document, and older template wording is easy to miss. An AI-based tender document reader can pull out the EMD, performance security and advance payment clauses as soon as you open a tender, flag whether surety bonds are named as acceptable, and show the validity and format requirements side by side. That lets you decide early whether to raise a pre-bid query, line up an insurer in time, and avoid finding out about a "bank guarantee only" clause at the submission stage. On highway tenders, it also helps to see, in one place, whether the document follows NHAI's updated security terms: the performance security percentage, the APS clause for low bids and the instrument allowed for it, the verification requirement for the bond, and the annexed format you need to use. That matters most when you are pricing a deep discount, since it tells you early how much of the security has to come from your bank.

SHARE
Get relevant business leads faster with our AI based recommendations

FAQs

Yes. The amendment covers both bid security (EMD) and performance security. IRDAI's guidelines also allow insurers to issue advance payment bonds. Micro and small enterprises are exempt from EMD in the first place, so the bond matters most for non-exempt bidders and for performance security.

Yes, in central government procurement under GFR 2017. The Department of Expenditure's office memorandum dated 2 February 2022 added insurance surety bonds to Rules 170(i) and 171(i) as an accepted form of bid security and performance security. Check the tender document, since individual buyers' clauses and non-GFR procurement can differ.

Not always on premium alone. Indicative surety premiums are often quoted at around 0.5% to 3% a year, comparable to bank commissions. The saving usually comes from not locking cash margin or using up non-fund-based bank limits. Compare actual quotes from your bank and an insurer for the same amount and tenure.

Raise a pre-bid query asking the buyer to confirm acceptance of insurance surety bonds, citing GFR 2017 Rules 170(i) and 171(i) as amended in February 2022. If the buyer does not follow GFR, or does not amend the clause, plan to furnish a bank guarantee instead.